• Home
  • Flavors and Sizes
  • Place Your Order
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • Flavors and Sizes
    • Place Your Order
    • Contact
  • Home
  • Flavors and Sizes
  • Place Your Order
  • Contact

Evanly Cheesecakes Menu

Mini Cheesecakes

2-Pack Minis

$13

A perfect sampler of two handcrafted mini cheesecakes. Great for gifts, date nights, or a quick sweet fix.

4-Pack Minis

$24

A shareable (or not!) box of four mini cheesecakes in your choice of flavors.

12-Pack Minis

$70

Our most popular party box—twelve mini cheesecakes, beautifully packaged and perfect for gatherings.

12 Chocolate-Dipped Cheesecake Pops

$42

Bite-sized cheesecake pops dipped in rich chocolate and served on a stick. Fun, portable, and crowd-pleasing!


Standard Cheesecakes

4-Inch Cheesecake

$25

A personal-sized cheesecake perfect for 1–2 servings. Heart-shaped option available—mention in the order notes.

9-Inch Cheesecake

$90

Our most popular size for family gatherings and events. Serves 8–10 people. Heart-shaped available upon request.

10-Inch Cheesecake

$95

The largest option we offer—ideal for larger groups or celebrations. Serves 10–12.

For events

Large Order Packages

Perfect for weddings, office parties, and large events.

Seven 4-inch Cheesecakes

$125

An elegant dessert setup for intimate events. Choose your favorite flavors to mix and match.

Two 9-inch Cheesecakes

$160

Great for serving larger groups with two flavor options.

Two 10-inch Cheesecakes

$175

Ideal for large events, this combo serves up premium presentation and plenty of dessert.


Mini & Pop Pricing:

50–200 minis (cupcake size)

$4.75 each

Individually portioned minis for weddings, receptions, or dessert tables. Minimum quantity: 50.

20+ minis

$4.25 each

Discounted pricing for mini cheesecake orders over 20 pieces. Great for mid-sized events.

24–150 cheesecake pops or tinies

$3.50 each

Our signature cheesecake pops or bite-sized “tinies,” available in your favorite flavors.

151+ cheesecake pops or tinies

$3.25 each

Bulk pricing for large events or corporate catering. Includes individually portioned, high-quality desserts.

Delivery Info

How Delivery Works

Evanly Cheesecakes is a delivery-only business, bringing handcrafted cheesecakes directly to your door or event. We deliver throughout Chicago and the surrounding suburbs, including Evanston, Oak Park, Naperville, and anywhere within a two-hour radius of the city. Orders are made fresh and scheduled to arrive on time for your special occasion.

Delivery Fees & Minimums

To qualify for delivery, we require a minimum cheesecake order of $40. Delivery fees range from $5 to $10, depending on your location. Once you place your order using our Google Form, we’ll follow up within 24 hours to confirm your order, delivery details, and final pricing.

Flavor List

Turtle Temptation

A rich, creamy cheesecake topped with gooey caramel, toasted pecans, and a drizzle of chocolate. It’s everything you love about turtle candies—in cheesecake form.

Baklava Bliss

Our spin on the Mediterranean classic. This cheesecake features layers of phyllo, honey, and crushed nuts, delivering flaky, sticky-sweet perfection in every bite.

Sinfully S’mores

Angelic Apple Caramel

A nostalgic twist on a campfire favorite. This cheesecake is topped with toasted marshmallow, chocolate drizzle, and a buttery graham cracker crunch.

Angelic Apple Caramel

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

Angelic Apple Caramel

Sweet cinnamon-spiced apples meet silky cheesecake and buttery caramel. It’s like a caramel apple and a cheesecake had a delicious baby.

Saintly Strawberry

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

A fan favorite. Our signature cheesecake topped with fresh, juicy strawberries and a sweet strawberry glaze. Light, fruity, and timeless.

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

Chocolate Mousse Miracle

Layers of dark chocolate cheesecake and velvety mousse, finished with a chocolate drizzle. A chocolate lover’s dream come true.

Cheery Cherry

Espresso Excellence Chocolate Mousse

Beloved Blueberry Crumble

A classic done right—our rich cheesecake topped with bright red cherries and just the right touch of tart. The perfect balance of sweet and nostalgic.

Beloved Blueberry Crumble

Espresso Excellence Chocolate Mousse

Beloved Blueberry Crumble

This flavor pairs creamy cheesecake with a sweet blueberry topping and buttery oat crumble. Think of it as pie and cheesecake in one.

Espresso Excellence Chocolate Mousse

Espresso Excellence Chocolate Mousse

Espresso Excellence Chocolate Mousse

Bold espresso and smooth chocolate mousse combine in this flavor-packed cheesecake. It's rich, energizing, and indulgent—just like your favorite mocha.

Seasonal Flavors

Pumpkin Mousse Paradise

A fall favorite that’s as smooth as it is spiced. This cheesecake combines creamy pumpkin mousse with warm autumn flavors, finished with a drizzle of chocolate and a sprinkle of crushed pecans. Comfort in every bite.

Coveted Cranberry Crumble

Sweet, tart, and irresistibly festive. This cheesecake features a tangy cranberry swirl and a buttery streusel crumble topping—perfect for holiday tables and cozy winter nights.

Pristine Peppermint Chocolate Mousse

Pristine Peppermint Chocolate Mousse

Your favorite holiday combo in cheesecake form. This seasonal treat blends rich chocolate mousse with cool peppermint, then tops it with toasted marshmallow, chocolate drizzle, and a graham cracker crust for the ultimate winter indulgence.

Can’t decide? Let us create something just for you.

Order now

Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at 708-670-7204 if you cannot find an answer to your question.

Yes! You’re welcome to mix flavors in your mini cheesecake packs and large orders. Just use the “Notes” section on the order form to let us know what you’d like.


Our 4-inch is great for 1–2 people, 9-inch serves 8–10, and 10-inch serves 10–12. For larger events, we recommend ordering multiple sizes or a large order package.


Most flavors are available anytime, but we do have seasonal specials like Pumpkin Mousse and Peppermint Chocolate around the holidays. Check our current menu or contact us to confirm.


Yes! We offer 4-inch and 9-inch cheesecakes in a heart shape—just mention it in the Notes section of your order form.


At this time, we do not offer vegan or gluten-free cheesecakes. However, we’re always experimenting—feel free to reach out and ask about special dietary accommodations.


  • Privacy Policy

Evanly Cheesecakes

evanlycheesecakes@gmail.com

708-670-7204

Copyright © 2025 Evanly Cheesecakes - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept